On a brand new install, after adding over 200 members by hand I ran the tools and got only this error:
ERROR: sql query: SELECT u.id FROM #__users u LEFT JOIN #__core_acl_aro a ON a.section_value = 'users' AND a.value = CAST( u.id AS CHAR ) WHERE a.value IS NULL : returned error: Illegal mix of collations (utf8_unicode_ci,IMPLICIT) and (utf8_general_ci,IMPLICIT) for operation '=' SQL=SELECT u.id FROM jos_users u LEFT JOIN jos_core_acl_aro a ON a.section_value = 'users' AND a.value = CAST( u.id AS CHAR ) WHERE a.value IS NULL
Only problem I have with the member directory is that when logged in a user cannot view his own profile in the directory (but can edit it on the front end.) He can only view the profile normally on initial login. If he leaves it and goes back to view it, it just takes him back to the main directory list. I need a solution to that in particular.
I've already removed the two plugins i had to see if they were causing the error but found they arent the problem.