Feature Request : Picture in profile

17 years 11 months ago #12868 by ericc
As suggested :

It could be a good feature if the users could put only a link to an external website (as imageshack.us or other) for them picture in the profile instead of uploading it or choosing in the default gallery.

All forumboard propose this feature by default !!

Main avantage:
The size limit will be removed (done by the hosting)
No webspace "wasted" by 100 of users pictures
Less bandwidth used on your account. (sorry I have to pay for my bandwidth :blush: )

Thx for the good job already done

cheer

ericc

Please Log in to join the conversation.

17 years 11 months ago #12880 by nant
Replied by nant on topic Re:Feature Request : Picture in profile
If you want this feature to be considered you should post it to the forge.

Main disadvantages (at least some):

1. you never know the size of the image on the other side (performance problems etc)
2. no control over the contents of the actual image. It could start out as a nice picture (to pass the moderation stage) and end up as a XXX photo.

If you have a webspace problem you should really consider a new host B)

Please Log in to join the conversation.

17 years 11 months ago #12887 by ericc
Replied by ericc on topic Re:Feature Request : Picture in profile
... Ok I will post it to the forge .

Answers to your disavantage :

You can control the size of the picture directly from your side
[code:1]<img scr=$user_url width=80 height=80>[/code:1]

The picture is supposed to represent you . If you would like to show you to the rest of the world with a XXX picture, it's your problem not mine. :huh:
If it's a problem for you , you can always ask politely to the user to change is picture and in the worst case ban him ... :whistle:

Cheer

ericc

Please Log in to join the conversation.

17 years 11 months ago #12889 by Machiel
Replied by Machiel on topic Re:Feature Request : Picture in profile
It could be a nice feature but if they change the picture after it's moderated then you will have a problem. For you it isn't such a big problem when there are XXX photos on profiles. But I know enough sites where it is a problem.

Best Regards
Machiel

CB tester

Please Log in to join the conversation.

17 years 11 months ago #13125 by ericc
Replied by ericc on topic Re:Feature Request : Picture in profile
Hi

I just wonder how all forum who allow this , deal with this "potential" risk :S

May be they assume by default that the user is respectable and will not do that :whistle:

I admistrate forums and sites since a long time, before comming to Joomla, and I never face this kind of problem ... and this feature was always enabled (for the reason I explain .. save the bandwidth of the site ...)

The fact is that I use SMF as Forumboard on my site, and users can use link to them avatar to counter the limitation(s) of size (in SMF). So in any case, they already do it in the board ... I just want to allow them to do it in ALL the site and if possible with the same picture .


Cheer
ericc

Please Log in to join the conversation.

17 years 11 months ago #13141 by nant
Replied by nant on topic Re:Feature Request : Picture in profile
ericc wrote:

... Ok I will post it to the forge .

Answers to your disavantage :

You can control the size of the picture directly from your side
[code:1]<img scr=$user_url width=80 height=80>[/code:1]

The picture is supposed to represent you . If you would like to show you to the rest of the world with a XXX picture, it's your problem not mine. :huh:
If it's a problem for you , you can always ask politely to the user to change is picture and in the worst case ban him ... :whistle:

Cheer

ericc


Disadvantages still hold true.
If the original photo on the link is huge the profile page will take a long time to load.

And this would basically ruin the moderation aspect since you never know when the original photo changes since the link could stay the same.

Please Log in to join the conversation.

Moderators: beatnantkrileon
Time to create page: 0.221 seconds

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn