Strange, no idea what to suggest. PHP Mailer should be working fine. I don't see any issues with your settings. Best guess is the recipient email address is maybe causing issues. Have you tried other email addresses to see if those work? Do you have a different email configuration in AcyMailing that might explain why it works and CB doesn't? Does Joomlas mass mailer work? Also make sure you didn't disable CBs sending of emails within CB > Configuration > Integrations with the Send Emails parameter.