Wrong file uploaded for the second screen - ooops!


When the user clicks on Washington, she will only see the forum for the group she has joined - which is great !!

I'm not going to worry so much about the fact that the Forum index will show all the 1st level categories (states). I did change settings for the state level to be only viewed, posted, replied by a Super User. That only makes it disappear off the list so they can't access the 2nd level groups. That will have to stay the way it is.

However in your response "Your issue is likely that you've manually setup Kunena categories. The only Kunena category you need to manually create is the parent. Then on group create it'll generate the Kunena categories. " is not totally correct, at least in my case.
The GJ setup should be the same as Kunena. So per your instructions, I deleted all the subcategories of each state that were created manually. This left only the state categories. When I brought up each subcategory on the GJ side to resave and automatically create the forum category, I noticed that it ALSO created the top level category - state. So putting in the parent category was not necessary at all. GJ creates the entire tree.

The other thing I noticed is that in Kunena, the order you follow in having GJ create these categories is very important if you need them listed in a particular order - in my case, alphabetically by state. We get accustomed to being able to change the order of groups in GJ, but I found no way that Forum categories could be arranged manually. The order they are created is the way they will be displayed. So in summary, don't create the state categories in Forum first. And when you are opening and saving the counterpart groups in GJ, do them in the order you want them to appear in the Forum index.

Are my findings correct? If so, it should be included in documentation on either the GJ side or the Kunena side. Currently it is not mentioned in the documentation for either one.

I think we're on the same page???
On the GJ side I have categories already made for all 50 states. I also have the groups needed for each state setup. So that part is all completed.
On the Kunena side, 50 categories are setup with the Main Forum being the parent category. Because per instructions, I deleted ALL subcategories.

Now, on the GJ side, I pulled up each state group and just resaved it. It did create it's format counterpart. Each GJ group has their own state as their parent. I have a screenshot showing that saving the GJ group also created it's parent group, ie state.

Notice that the state categories of Alabama and Arkansas which I had set up manually are in sequential order. Ids: 316, 317. Once I saved JUST the groups for those states, it did create a new Alabama and Arkansas - Ids: 364 and 369.

If the top category you're referring to in Kunena is Main Forum, then this is what happened.

I also don't have any restrictions for a user to post in state categories that user is not a member of.



This user is only a member of one group - Washington trainers.



And his profile's forum activity is shown here: