Yes, I'm well aware of that notification setting, and my users know all about it also. I'm also aware of the Activity feed and I don't use the GJ Wall. That's not my issue.
I have all the user "Create of new activity post" on, again, that isn't my issue.
Let me see if I can describe it.
1. If I don't have CB Activity > Parameters > Notifications switched on then the nothing gets logged. There's an activity post, but there is no notification, even if I have all these other GJ settings on.
2. If I switch on the new CB Activity > Parameters > Notifications > Email then it sends an email to everyone in the database, not just to those in the GJ group.
What I'm needing is a very user specific email notification system for GJ that:
1. sends post emails (with the content) to all GJ group members only.
2. sends like emails to whomever made the post.
3. sends comment and reply emails to whomever is in the conversation inside a GJ Group.
4. same with GJ events and Gallery.
Right now it's a shotgun approach which sends emails sometimes to everyone, sometimes to the GJ group members, sometimes to no one or a few. Obviously if they have "Create of new activity post" switched on.
With the notification system it seems to work fine in updating the blue internal notification icons in the profile page (the mail and globe icons), they are very user specific and GJ specific. I thought it may be a simple thing to just send that our as an email, but it's proving very unpredictable.
I think I'll keep what I have for now, it seems like something's in the works that make make emails more specific.
Own Your Own Community!