I tried making the List itself accessible (via "User Group to allow access to") to "Everybody", but this didn't work. So I added "Allow Access to" "Everybody" in Configuration/User Profile (as mentioned above).
However this made my list STILL not accessible to non-registered users, but if a user had the URL of a member's profile then they could see it The exact opposite of what I need.
Please Log in to join the conversation.